SMALL BAITS FOR
COLD WEATHER STRIPERS
By Steve Baker
Originally Published January - February 1989
As old man winter pushes the water temperature past the 50 degree mark, old linesides makes a change himself As the stripers digestive tract and swimming movements slow down, tiny threadfin shad become his breakfast, lunch and dinner.

Last winter, shortly
after Christmas, old mother nature blessed our area here in East Tennessee
with a heavy blanket of snow. Cold frigid temperatures dipped down to the
low twenties at night making life nippy to say the least. As the front
passed and the wind finally died down, Norris lake took on a beautiful
but eerie characteristic. I saw little traffic on the lake and very little
on the roads near my home. The snow storm had virtually cut off all traffic
on the roads so you can imagine the quietness that hovered around the lake.
The deep snow around the banks seemed to paint the water jet black as the
bright sun finally broke through the clouds.
A friend of mine and
I had scheduled a fishing trip the day before but we decided to at least
let the wind die down before we made any decision about fishing on the
lake. As the sun finally broke, I knew I would get a phone call anytime
with a voice asking,"'when, where, and how?" Sure enough, I got that call
and my friend ask what was going on, (on the lake). I hadn't seen any fish
break as I had seen just before the storm. Here in this part of the country,
if you don't own a four wheeler in the winter months you simply don't get
around. My friend only had a family station wagon and I felt like it was
a bad choice to even roll out of the drive way. Like all stubborn fishermen,
my friend started out in the station wagon with a foot of snow on the roads.
I told him if he could make the 20 mile drive without running off a bluff.
we would surely catch a striper.
As we got in the boat,
he ask what the stripers were hitting and I just turned and grinned. I
headed out to a big open water section of the main lake that maintains
100 foot plus depths even during the winter draw down of 65 or 70 feet.
I stopped on a couple of spots before reaching the deep water holes but
I saw no sign of activity on the surface or on my graph. I have to admit,
at first I figured my friend's only excitement would be sliding sideways
down the road coming into the dock area.
Looking across the
big open water which was dead calm, I saw a large number of seagulls diving
and flying around one general area. The sound of the screeching gulls could
be heard for several hundred yards in the quietness that usually accompanies
a heavy snow storm. I idled closer to the gulls hoping to see the water
thrashing with vicious feeding stripers. When I got close enough to see
what was going on, I noticed huge swirls in an area twice as big as a football
field. There were literally hundreds of swirls and not one fish broke water
with any aggression. Water temperature hovered at 48 degrees and the cold
water had pushed schools of threadfin shad over deep water. In some areas,
the shad were actually 30 to 50 feet thick. I sat and watched the feeding
stripers for a few moments hoping to get a helpful hint on some sort of
strategy that would make my friend's slippery ride worth all the effort.
The stripers were feeding lazily on the very small threadfins which were
only about 1½ to 2 inches long. The water was clear and the fish
weren't very spookable so you could actually see what was happening.
Big stripers in the 18 to
25 pounds class would chase a small handful of the small baits out of the
school and simply swim slowly behind until they decided to go in for the
kill. The stripers then would only swirl the water as they took the baits.
I had run into a similar situation the week before and all I
had was big shad and large Redfins and I never caught a fish. The small
threadfins would go through the mesh on the cast net or get hung in the
mesh injuring the bait too badly to use. I had bought several dozen medium
sized tuffy crappie minnows which were about the size of the small threadfins.
These minnows definitely stand up to name "tuffy" because I have had the
water freeze on my minnow bucket and the small minnows keep on kicking
so the cold water in the lake has no affect. I put on a small Mustad Special
live bait hook and put a small 1/4 ounce split shot about 18 inches above
the hook. I rigged a small snap on crappie bobber and set it at 10 feet
deep.
My friend looked at
me as if I was out of my mind for fishing such a ridiculous rig for a 20
pound fish. Before he said anything, I handed him a rod and told him to
let the bait out about 100 feet behind the boat. As I turned to dip out
another small minnow, a big striper inhaled my buddy's tuffy minnow just
as he started to let it out. For about an hour before the wind started
to blow, we caught fish as fast as we could get the small baits into the
water. We didn't have a fish under 15 pounds and had several that would
have pushed 20 pounds. On that particular day, the fish would not even
swirl a Redfin or any other top water offering.
Of all the troubled
situations I have seen anglers try to cope with, this one seems to give
them the most problems. Stripers do not feed on small bait fish because
of a lack of big gizzard shad or herring. This is a body chemistry made
up that is triggered by cold water conditions in the winter and early spring.
Just as with any other species of fish making a transitional change, not
all stripers will feed on small baits in the early fall or late spring
as the water first begins to cool off or warm up. In late fall or early
winter, the water temperature will usually go down past fifty degrees and
this will force almost all stripers to feed on very small bait fish. The
cold water slows the digestive system of the striper and also slows down
the normally quick swimming movement as a striper chases on baitfish. Don't
think for one minute that a striper will get sluggish after he is hooked
in the cold winter months. The cold water conditions work in favor of the
striper during a tug-of-war between you and a big fish. However, most surface
feeding fish will swirl the water instead of explosive actions that occur
in warm water conditions.
The small bait pattern
is a pattern triggered by cold water and not necessarily a pattern for
any individual lake. I have found it to work on several lakes around the
country during the winter months. There are several tricks of the trade
that I have found that will help catch fish on a consistent basis. Locating
stripers during the winter months is not a difficult task because there
is no thermocline and the stripers are usually scattered over the entire
lake. One pattern I have noticed is that most large schools of fish will
be located over deep water. Underwater structure doesn't seem to play a
dominating role in fish location simply because the large schools of threadfin
shad are roaming the deep water and naturally the striper will follow in
hot pursuit. Deep water conditions usually are found around the old river
channel. Water depths are obviously different on most lakes but as I have
mentioned the deep open water area seems to be where most fish are located.
One of the most important
factors using this pattern is the wind. As we all know, it is hard to pin
point a day during the winter when we have no wind and slick water conditions.
Surface feeding stripers will work around areas that are protected from
the wind. I have noticed that even during a slight breeze that will create
a small ripple on the surface the feeding activity will move around just
outside the ripple line, I don't know if the wind forces the shad down
or the surface disturbance actually drives the striper away but in most
cases the fish will stay around areas of slick water on the surface. If
you must plan your trip regardless of weather conditions and you are forced
to put up with the wind, you may look for big schools of bait on your graph
or video. I have found that if the bait is stacked up it is a wise choice
to stop and put out a couple of baits. The wind doesn't turn the fish off
it simply means riding and looking for the gulls or surface feeding action.
Water color is another
factor that will make a good day either great or terrible. If I had my
way, I would also prefer very clear water when using small baits. I feel
this is a mechanical factor that the stripers can see the smaller baits
in clear water and come up from very deep water to strike. When fishing
deep open water, water color is usually not much of a problem. The rain
run off in the feeder creeks has plenty of time to settle before hitting
the main body of the lake and clear water can almost always be found during
the winter months in the big open expanse of water.
Both live bait and
small artificial can be extremely productive when fishing cold water. I
have tried using the small thread-fin, catching them with a very small
mesh cast net. The trouble with these baits is they are usually already
weak from the cold water. When put on a line, the baits won't usually last
over 10 or 15 minutes. They may not actually die but they don't have enough
strength to keep in an upright natural swimming position. The small tuffy
crappie minnows are very handy and will stay alive on a hook for hours
at a time. Shiners are good as well as creek minnows and sometimes goldfish
are a good choice. The type of minnow is not the deciding factor in cold
water. The size of the bait is the most important item. I never use a bait
much longer than 3 inches. I have caught big stripers on baits only 1 1/2
inches long.
When rigging for these
small baits, I prefer 14 pound test line. I've tried lighter line with
the tiny minnows but I never can get a good solid hook set on a 8 or 10
pound line because of the distance the bait is run behind the boat and
the stretch in the line. The size of the split shot will vary due to another
if the wind picks up. I like to use as small a bobber as I can. A small
bobber of 1 inch in diameter will usually get the job done. The depth of
the bobber may vary in different lakes but I have found that 8 to 12 feet
is sufficient on most lakes. The trick is to put the baits out far enough
behind the boat. I like to stagger two or three rigs to prevent tangling.
I usually put the first bait out around 30 yards and stagger the other
at 20 feet intervals. During the cold water feeding periods, most stripers
will take the bait very lightly. I always put my reels in gear and
put them in heavy duty good rod holders. When a striper hits, the
hook will almost always be just inside the edge of his mouth. I have tried
fishing weighted baits fished 25 to 40 feet deep, after seeing a large
school of fish on my graph. I have caught a few fish but the striper's
feeding zone seems to be from the surface down to 10 or 15 feet deep.
Several artificial
lures are good but again the lure size is the important factor. Small bucktails
are good producers. I have always been partial to white 80% of the time
and chanteuse the remainder of the time. When choosing a bucktail, again
the weight of the lure is determined by the wind. I have found a 3/8 ounce
weight a good choice. I never put on any trailer during the winter
months. The trailers will add a few more inches in length to the bait that
is usually a turn off to the striper. Anglers who prefer plastic baits
may find the sassy shad by Mister Twister or a white or chartreuse curly
tail by Mister Twister in a small 3', size. Both lures work best with a
¼ or 3/8 ounce head. When casting bucktails and grubs, be cautious
on the depth you present your lures. If the fish are on the surface, don't
let the bait fall too deep. If the stripers are showing up on your graph
at 25 feet, be sure and let the baits fall in the strike zone just above
the striper's head.
Spoons are good
choices because of the close resemblance to the small thread-fins. Accetta
spoons has just brought back the Mr. Champ spoon. The bait is available
in different weights for casting or vertical jigging. The ½ ounce
size in a nickel finish has always produced fish for me during bright and
sunny days. The Accetta Pet spoons, with a small feather on the rear, can
be a good choice when the fish are on the surface. I often use a light
weight spoon 1/4 ounce fished 5 or 6 feet under a bobber for easy casting
and presentation for good results.
Eppinger manufacturers who have been making spoons for many years
for the big trout and musky anglers has just introduced several spoons
designed especially for the striper anglers. They have one design with
a shad pattern paint finish and another with a rainbow trout finish. These
lures have already taken several big stripers and should be one of the
honest lures to hit the market in years. These new spoons also come in
several sizes and weights that can be cast to breaking fish or worked to
a deep school during a brisk wind.
Whether you are a
live bait fanatic or a lure chunker, cold water striper fishing calls for
one thing, Small Baits. Don't he a statistic who tells a story of "they
were everywhere but I couldn't get 'um to bite."
![]()